Navigating the Shifting GTA Real Estate Market: What September 2025 Reveals & How to Win

​

September 2025 may be remembered as a turning point for GTA real estate. Buyers are returning, sellers are adapting, and the long-predicted downward pressure on prices is increasingly evident. For those watching—wanting to buy, sell, or invest—understanding the real meaning behind the numbers is critical.

​

 

In this post, we unpack TRREB’s September data, bring in deeper insights from recent commentary, and explore strategies you can use right now to navigate this evolving market.

​

 

1. Sales Rising, But Still Historically Low

While an 8.5 % year-over-year increase in sales sounds encouraging, the context tempers the enthusiasm. In fact, September’s 5,592 sales represent one of the weakest Septembers in the past two decades — approximately 27.4 % below the 10-year average.

 

That means — yes, more buyers are stepping forward, but volume is still modest relative to population growth, household formation, and historic norms. Many buyers remain on the sidelines, watching to see whether rate cuts and inventory shifts materially alter the risk-reward dynamics.

​

2. Price Declines Accelerating, Benchmark Values Adjusting

The data clearly shows downward movement:

• Composite Benchmark Index: –5.5 % year-over-year

• Average sales price: –4.7 % YoY

The typical home price has dropped 24.9 % from their February 2022 peaks, with the September benchmark hitting roughly $963,000. This suggests not only a correction, but a structural shift in what the GTA premium can command in a higher rate environment.

​

Importantly, price declines are broad-based — not limited to distressed or fringe listings. The low sales-to-new-listings ratio (just 29 %) is itself a strong signal of downward pressure: too many homes chasing too few buyers.

​

3. Inventory Flood: The Buyer’s Upper Hand

One of the most striking changes: inventory is exploding.

• Active listings reached 29,394 in September — up 18.9 % YoY.

• New listings in September (19,260) were 16 % above the 10-year average.

This level of inventory dwarfs even levels seen during the 1990s market correction, implying that the supply side is now driving market dynamics more than demand.

What changes when inventory is plentiful? Buyers get more choices. Sellers must refine their pricing and marketing strategy. And friction in decision-making increases (i.e. buyers can procrastinate, sellers must create urgency).

​

4. Interest Rates & the Bank of Canada: A Delicate Balancing Act

The Bank of Canada’s September interest rate cut (to 2.50 %) gave the market a jolt of optimism. Lower borrowing costs mean monthly payments become more manageable, which draws more households into the “affordable” bracket. TRREB leadership cited this directly as a spur to renewed buyer activity.

​

However, recent reporting suggests the Bank itself is cautious. In its own meeting notes, it recognizes that rate cuts alone cannot “fix” broader economic issues. There’s also risk: moving too fast could stoke inflation or destabilize lending markets.

So while further cuts are likely (many analysts expect multiple 25bps moves through 2026), they may be gradual, and the lag before market impact will matter.

​

 

5. What This Means for Buyers, Sellers & Investors

​

Stakeholder
 

Homebuyers -Increased choice, negotiating leverage - Get pre-approved, move quickly when comps align, explore all deals

Home sellers -Pressure to price competitively, attract attention - Stage well, spotlight value-add, be open to faster closings or incentives

Investors / Flippers - Risk increased with holding costs, but upside on undervalued assets -Target undervalued segments, use conservative cashflow models, diversify locations

​

Neighbourhood nuance matters. For example, what’s happening in East York or Scarborough may differ from Yorkville or North York. Always compare your local micro-market against these macro trends.

​

6. How to Play It Smart (2025–2026)

1. Track leading indicators — mortgage rate announcements, absorption trends, sales-to-listings ratios.

2. Be nimble — delays in listing or decision-making can cost thousands as market moves.

3. Data-backed pricing — use up-to-date comparable sales and trend data (including September’s shifts).

4. Cash reserves matter — in a softening market, flexibility wins (e.g. ability to hold longer, incur lower discounting).

5. Stay connected & informed — new policies, lending rule changes, or macro shifts can swiftly shift the balance.

 

Conclusion

September 2025’s data underscores a market in transition: softening prices, record inventory, and tentative buyer re-engagement. It’s a more balanced—or even buyer-leaning—environment than the red-hot market of prior years.

If you want to understand exactly where your neighbourhood fits in (York Region? Peel? Toronto East? West End?), or how to time your move, I’d be glad to build a custom market report for you. Reach out via email or contact me to explore how the current shift can work for you.